Was This the Worst Referee Decision Ever?

March 5th, 2010

I am not a big fan of  talking about Aston Villa issues (as I am almost certainly going to be biased) or about criticising referees, as I have officiated games and know how difficult it can be, but Phil Dowd’s decision in the Carling Cup final still urks me. Upon reading Martin O’Neill’s reaction to the decision, and after a week to dwell on my thoughts, I find myself becoming increasing frustrated. O’Neill makes a great point, it is not that Dowd missed the called, he gave a penalty that was in little doubt. However, to not issue a red card (or even a yellow) was not enforcing the laws of the game, which is the job of the referee. It should be noted that I do not blame Dowd for the loss, after all, a 10 man United team outplayed Villa at Villa Park a few weeks earlier. By not sending Vidic off however, the referee had a direct influence on the outcome of the game, which is the exact opposite of what a referee should do. I find it hard to believe anyone can argue this is not a red card offense.

 

Podcast # 45 – Poor Villa… Go Canada!

March 3rd, 2010

newpodcast-copy1Eho!  Canada wins Gold but the same joy wasn’t shared by Matt (well it was 3 pints later) but their is still a many of talking points from the previous week.  England comes back, Spain wins in France and dont forget the non-shake by Bridge and Terry…  We also give our Chelsea team of the decade… Enjoy!

 

Incredible blOWN-Goal

March 3rd, 2010

That play on words is awesome, but not as awesome as this goal.

Smithy Man-U Workout

March 1st, 2010


If you haven’t seen his England bit watch this.

TFC v. FC Dallas – Review & Ratings

February 25th, 2010

Just like I did when TFC was in Charleston I decided I should do some player ratings again.  Player Ratings are strange but I tried to base them around individual efforts.  If I got anything wrong I’m sorry, it was hard to watch between the choppy stream,  no commentary and difficulty identifying players.

Game Summary

The match started off surprisingly smooth with the ball flowing between teams.  Kayizzi took his chance well after being put in alone with the keeper.  10′ later Frei absolutely robbed Chavez twice. Stream froze for two minutes but game seemed to have picked up where it left off.  Ferreira then had a little spat throwing his arms out at Kayizzi after he thought he was fouled by Saric.  Referee just gave a warning, probably right decision. Kayizzi then with some great work almost set up the second as he cut in from the right after stealing a clearance attempt.  Fight breaks out as Garcia appears to swing at a player and is then sent off.  The first half comes to completion.

Second half starts off the subs are as confusing as ever.  Kocic (trialist just waived by DC) makes a great save on Ferreira then looks like Jammeh cleans up rebound.  Dallas controls majority of the possession with exception of one TFC corner-kick.  More substitutions are made and my job just got incredibly tough.  Kocic then took a knock after diving for a ball.  Trialists are unlucky right now considering Garcia is gone.  Uphill battle for them. Game slows down as Saric is hurt on the pitch after a good counter-attack from TFC.  Making sense of these trialists is hard as even the TFC staff is confused in the live blog.  Dallas almost scores as the ball runs through the box.  Falls to Dallas player but whiffs.  TFC let off the hook. Great play by Ijeh with 5 minutes left, worked well by himself against 3 players to win a free-kick.  Kocic makes an awesome save, playing just as good as Frei did in the first half.  Blown coverage allows for a good cross but Kocic parries away.  Last minute of the game and Dallas get a free kick and it appears Kocic puts it onto the post!  Incredible!  The ref blows and TFC wins 1-0 over FC Dallas.

Conclusion

Very hard to judge the trialists in this game considering Garcia being sent off but Kayizzi looked very up for it but he was on the field when TFC had 11 men.  It was tough to distinguish them apart and I’d like to see all the trialists on the field.  De Rosario looks to be in fine form as usual and JDG seems to be gelling.  The game really was a story of two goalkeepers on the same team.  Without Frei or Kocic playing so well it could of been 4 goals for Dallas.  When I saw the free kick dip behind the wall I figured nothing had changed but either Kocic put it on the post or it just simply hit the post.  Regardless 1-0 to TFC and playing the game with 10 men.  Pleasing effort.

Player Ratings

Frei - 9.5 - Two great saves on Dallas striker Chavez, the first a chip, the second a drive.  Frei looks to be in great shot stopping form.  Subbed at half after stopping 3 goals.

Attakora6.5 - Tested over the top a lot.  Didn’t give up much in first half. Looks okay at right back.  Was moved to CB after Garcia was sent off.  Looks more comfortable.

Jammeh6 - Whiffed at a ball early in the game, lucky to not be punished.  Did well to clean-up a few times.

Garcia1 - Slow, clumsy high foot early on and could be to blame for both of Chavez’s chances.  Around 24′ missed a header that almost costed them.  Three obvious errors, bad passing.  Sent off in the last minute of the first half.  It honestly looks like he’s trying to engineer a move away from Toronto.

Kayizzi8 - Maybe lucky on the finish, but did well to make the run in acres of space.  Almost set up the second late in the first half. Very good. Off at around 65′

De Guzman7 - Lively in the first half.  Did well to control midfield.  Subbed at 60′.  Good performance and the game looks to flow through him.

Saric7 – Awesome pass to De-Ro, early on, Xabi Alonso’esque.  Clumsy challenge for the yellow.  Tough task in the second half hard to rate performance, don’t know what Preki told him about his deep-midfield role.  Handled the set-pieces but nothing really in scoring range, but played a good ball that almost got a head on it.

Gala5.5 – Wasn’t bad, didn’t really see much of him though. Subbed at Half

De Rosario – 7.5 – Looks to of played in Kayizzi.  If so great vision and a good pass. Hustled hard.  Subbed at half.

Gerba4 - Subbed at half.  Did very little.

Substitutions (Hard to separate Trialists)

Milos Kocic - 9 – Waived by DC earlier in the week.  Really aggressive and sacrificed body to stop  a ball coming in the box.  Played very well with 2 or 3 good saves.

Cronin - 7 - Played middle of the park.  Did well to slow things down considering being a man down.

Nane Joseph4.5 - Few touches on the ball.  Was caught out of position but was bailed out by an awesome save by Kocic.  Needs work to settle in.

Peter Ijeh - 6.5 - Nigerian on trial.  Has some awesome dreadlocks.  Had a nice pass on counter-attack to find White or Dan Gargan.

White - 6 – Nice to see him in these games.  Hopefully that knee holds up all season.  Looked like he was played outta position on the left somehow.

Dan Gargan – 5 – Didn’t see much, hard to judge.

Ibad Mohamadu - 6 – Up against it considering the cirumstances and played okay.

Wynne6.5 - Came on, nice to see him back, expecting a lot from him to play better then he did last season.  Cleaned up well and maybe even brought some cooler heads to the unstable back-line.

Podcast # 44 – Wembley Villaware?

February 25th, 2010

newpodcast-copy1

It’s another Olympic edition.   But we also find Ashely Cole’s iPod… Just listen… I’m going to bed..

 

Podcast # 43 – Bilodeau wins Gold!!! … I mean…. football..

February 17th, 2010

newpodcast-copy1Episode #43 is a laboured, drawn out podcast.  Piss off their are Olympics on!  Anyway we go over the the major talking points (Matt forgets Sydney FC) and Matt gives his Munich XI.  Ok, I’m sorry everyone but it is the Olympics.

Enjoy!

 

Fixed Link (Cheers Dustin)

Sounds from the Pub – Super Wednesday

February 12th, 2010

Arsenal v. Liverpool, Villa v. UTD., Everton v. Chelsea.

Shout out to everyone who came.

 

Podcast # 42 – Euro Draw and Derby Delight

February 10th, 2010

newpodcast-copy1Heyo, it’s our weekly podcast that is just in time for you to miss as you prepare for your Wednesday games (Come to Dicks btw).  Anyway, Matt and I go over all of the highlights from the past week and we discuss the latest Euro draw.  We also reveal some incoming TFC information that is sure to upset a few people… Enjoy Podcast #42!

 

TFC and Adrian Serioux

February 4th, 2010

It emerged yesterday that Adrian Serioux has been released by Toronto FC, something that came as a shock to most supporters of the club. Duane Rollins of The 24th Minute reacted somewhat angrily to the news, more so the way it was handled than the actual decision itself. There may well be a case to be made that TFC should have handled the release of the information better, but at the end of the day it has been done and a press release would not have made Serioux any more comfortable with the decision I would assume.

At the end of last season when the postmortem began, most people believed Serioux should be held onto, but as a utility player and the bonus of him being Canadian, rather than a key player in the starting XI. It was also becoming obvious that Serioux has developed a persistent, if not serious neck injury which prevents him for playing consistently and at his best. In a league with a salary cap where every cent is crucial, a tough decision has been made, and looking at the end of last season it is easy to understand why this decision has been made. It has been suggested this neck injury could mean the end of Serioux’s career, obviously I and everyone else in the game would wish him well and hope he can continue his career, be it at TFC or elsewhere.

The up side to the high player turnover this winter is that it would appear that Preki is being given a free rein to shape the squad he wants, and before the season begins (novel idea!). This may be down to the fact he has MLS experience, or that Mo knows and trusts his opinion (or possibly a little of both). The end result is going to be a manager working with a squad of players he has chosen and trusts. In a league that is so tightly contested and a massively disappointing TFC only just missed the playoffs last season, 2010 could be the season MLS is fully introduced to the sleeping giant of TFC.